ADVERTISEMENT

Muthoot Finance Set to Shine: Morgan Stanley Favours It Over Manappuram Following Gold Loan Rule Changes

2025-06-09
Muthoot Finance Set to Shine: Morgan Stanley Favours It Over Manappuram Following Gold Loan Rule Changes
CNBCTV18

Auckland, NZ – In a recent report, Morgan Stanley has highlighted Muthoot Finance as a compelling investment opportunity, suggesting it could outperform Manappuram Finance in the wake of new gold loan regulations. Despite the stock’s recent positive performance, Morgan Stanley remains bullish, citing a robust earnings forecast for both the first quarter of FY26 and the full fiscal year.

Understanding the Regulatory Shift

The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) recently introduced new guidelines for gold loans, impacting the operations and profitability of Non-Banking Financial Companies (NBFCs) like Muthoot Finance and Manappuram. These changes primarily focus on stricter loan-to-value (LTV) ratios, enhanced risk management practices, and greater transparency in gold valuation. While these rules aim to safeguard borrowers and ensure the stability of the financial system, they also create a dynamic where certain players are better positioned than others to navigate the new landscape.

Why Muthoot Finance Stands Out

Morgan Stanley's analysis indicates that Muthoot Finance is particularly well-equipped to capitalise on these evolving conditions. Several factors contribute to this positive outlook:

  • Strong Q1 & FY26 Earnings Forecast: The firm anticipates a solid performance in the upcoming quarter and throughout the fiscal year, driven by efficient operations and a loyal customer base.
  • Strategic Branch Network: Muthoot Finance boasts a widespread and strategically located branch network, providing it with a significant reach and competitive advantage in securing gold loan business across various regions.
  • Prudent Risk Management: The company’s proactive approach to risk management, including rigorous gold valuation processes and adherence to regulatory guidelines, positions it favourably under the new RBI norms.
  • Diversified Product Portfolio: While gold loans remain a core business, Muthoot Finance has been steadily diversifying its product offerings, mitigating risk and expanding revenue streams.

Comparing Muthoot Finance and Manappuram

While Manappuram Finance is also a significant player in the gold loan market, Morgan Stanley believes Muthoot Finance possesses a more resilient business model and a better ability to adapt to the regulatory changes. The report suggests that Manappuram might face greater challenges in maintaining its profitability due to a potentially higher reliance on gold loans and a less diversified product portfolio.

Investment Implications for Kiwi Investors

For New Zealand-based investors looking to diversify their portfolios with exposure to the Indian financial market, Muthoot Finance presents an interesting opportunity. While direct investment may require navigating international brokerage platforms, the potential for capital appreciation, as highlighted by Morgan Stanley, warrants careful consideration. It's crucial to conduct thorough due diligence and consult with a financial advisor before making any investment decisions.

Disclaimer: This analysis is based on a report by Morgan Stanley and should not be considered financial advice. Investment decisions should be made based on individual circumstances and after consulting with a qualified financial professional.

ADVERTISEMENT
Recommendations
Recommendations